For agenda item 4, “Snow removal contract,” at the board meeting on Wednesday, November 4, 2026, 8:30 PM MT. Compiled that day from the HOA’s documents, FCS’s emails, NOAA snow records and the companies’ own websites.
Received. Logan Landscaping & Maintenance, the HOA’s current landscaper, quoted sidewalk snow removal for the 2026–27 season (prepared for Jim Orr; he shared it with the board on Nov 5, 2026):
| Snow accumulation | Price per service |
|---|---|
| 1″–3″ | $695.00 |
| 3″–5″ | $845.00 |
| Over 5″ | priced separately |
Per snow removal event; sidewalks only (driveways and parking areas excluded). Its bands start at 1″, while the board wants service at 2″ or more. It covers “designated East Mountain HOA sidewalks” and doesn’t say which.
Received. Lawn Thumbs (American Fork) replied on Nov 9, 2026, for the sidewalks on the snow removal area map, which it measured at about 62,000 sq ft:
| Service | Price per visit |
|---|---|
| Shoveling, salt included | $3,189.00 |
| Salt only (no shoveling) | $1,269.00 |
| Drive fee, each visit | $40.00 |
One price per push, at any depth; we call for each visit at the 2″ trigger. The crew arrives at noon or later. It can provide proof of liability insurance. About four times Logan’s price.
Requested. On November 6, 2026, David McLaughlin, president of the association, emailed requests for quotes to ten more companies, asking for replies by the end of the following week. Each request asked for a price per visit for 2–6″ and over 6″, any minimum and ice-melt charges, response time, insurance and references, for the sidewalks on the snow removal area map (about 10,400 feet, as Jim Orr confirmed). Service would be at 2″ or more, with each visit confirmed by phone first. The ten were picked for their Google reviews, whether they do snow removal or commercial grounds work, and nearness; all list an email address.
| Company | Based in | Google rating (reviews) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Logan Landscaping & Maintenance | Provo | 5.0 (5) | Quoted Nov 5, 2026 (to Jim Orr) |
| Lawn Thumbs | American Fork | 4.7 (351) | Quoted Nov 9, 2026 |
| Marbella Landscaping | Orem | 4.4 (253) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| Millburn Lawn & Landscape | West Jordan | 4.5 (231) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| Activescapes Landscaping & Snow Removal | Holladay | 4.9 (198) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| C&C Grounds Maintenance | Utah County | 5.0 (34) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| JEM Yardcare | Mapleton | 4.9 (30) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| United Brothers Landscaping & Snow Removal | Provo | 4.8 (22) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| Provo Snow Removal | Provo | 5.0 (10) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| Dedicated Groundsmen | Provo / Orem | 4.6 (7) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
| Goosenest Lawn Care & Snow Plowing | Elk Ridge | 5.0 (2) | Requested Nov 6, 2026; waiting for a reply |
On the home Wi-Fi or VPN, this table has a check box for each reply, a box for the quote and one for notes; they save as you type.
Google ratings as of Nov 6, 2026. Logan Landscaping wasn’t emailed again, since it has already quoted.
The bills rise and fall with the snow, so the HOA has been paying per visit, not a flat seasonal contract. A seasonal contract bills about the same every winter; East Mountain’s bill went from $11,425 to $0 to $1,254. The budgets also count visits (“based on 2″–6″ … 7 pushes”).
But each visit has been expensive. Recent winters have needed about one visit, and that visit cost about $1,250:
| Year | Snowfalls of 2″+ at Provo BYU | Paid | Paid per snowfall |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 8: Jan 2, Jan 29, Feb 22, Feb 27, Mar 5, Mar 6, Mar 24, Apr 4 | $11,425 | about $1,430 |
| 2024 | 3: Jan 5, Jan 11, Feb 4 | $0 | nothing billed |
| 2025 | 1: Mar 7 (3.1″) | $1,254 | about $1,254 |
| 2026 | 1 so far: Feb 18 (3.1″) | not yet known | — |
Calendar years, the way the budget counts them; NOAA daily records. “Paid per snowfall” assumes one visit per 2-inch snowfall. If the crew also came for smaller snows or for ice, each visit cost less: 2025 had 6 days with an inch or more. 2024’s $0 means either no service was bought that winter or it was billed under another line.
How to settle it tonight:
| Option | How it’s priced | Light | Typical | Heavy | Per owner a month* |
|---|
*Typical winter, spread across 97 homes and 12 months. Per-push estimates are rate × snowfalls; a seasonal price is the same in any winter.
timely and thorough snow removal following snowfalls of two inches or more, along with ice control on slippery surfacesThey also say crews clear the main ways in and out first in big storms, and that the vendor serves other properties too (“The HOA does not employ a dedicated snow removal service”).
| Year | Actual | Budget | Note |
|---|
Snow removal is a line in the operating budget, from the 2025 and 2026 budget comparisons. 2026’s actual isn’t in the documents yet; the 9/30/2026 financials are on the FCS portal. Earlier years aren’t in any document or email on hand.
Price per push implied by the budgets: 2025, $5,800 ÷ 7 = about $829; 2026, $3,200 ÷ 12 = about $267. What was actually paid per snowfall was higher still; see “Per visit or a contract?” above. FCS’s December 2023 notice raised dues partly because of it: “2022–2023 was a high snow year that used roll-over cash (savings) from years past.”
| When | Snow removal by | Cost | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Winter 2016–17 | Green Grass Grows, then the HOA’s landscaping company, was believed to be in charge of sidewalk snow removal. | — | A neighbor’s post in the East Mountain Facebook group, Feb 24, 2017 |
| Winter 2017–18 | “Our snow removal person” (not named) cleared neighborhood sidewalks. | — | Facebook group post, Mar 4, 2018 |
| 2018–2022 | FCS Community Management (HOALiving) manages the HOA; no email names the snow vendor. | — | FCS emails |
| 2023 | Not named. FCS’s storm notice of Feb 22, 2023 refers to “your snow removal contractor.” | $11,425 | Storm notice, 2025 budget |
| 2024 | Wheelhouse Service had the landscape contract from Mar 27, 2024. No snow removal was paid for. | $0 | Actions without a meeting |
| 2025 | Landscapers changed three times: Ivy Lawncare (signed Jun 3, fired Aug 19 “for poor quality of work”), Silverback Property Services (Aug 20), Logan Landscape (Oct 6). The vendor behind the snow bill isn’t named. | $1,254 | Actions without a meeting, 2026 budget |
| 2026 | Logan Landscape: on Dec 3, 2025 the board added them “to do the snow removal and landscaping 2026.” | budget $3,200 | Actions without a meeting |
| Winter 2026–27 | On tonight’s agenda. | Agenda |
The vendor on each snow invoice is in FCS’s general ledger on the HOALiving portal, if the board wants the 2023 and 2025 names.
| Winter | Days 2″+ | Days 1″+ | Total snowfall |
|---|
Days with 2 inches or more of new snow at NOAA’s Provo BYU station (USC00427064), July to June, from the station’s daily records. 2014–15 is the first of 12 winters with a complete record. A snow day isn’t exactly a push: a long storm can need two, and ice-only visits are extra. Snow amounts near East Mountain can differ from BYU’s. Last winter was dry as well as warm (under an inch of precipitation every month from November to March), so Logan Landscape has had almost nothing to clear yet.
| Type | How it bills | Who carries the weather risk | For East Mountain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per push (per visit) | A set price each time the crew clears the site. | The HOA: more storms, more pushes. | Best fit. At $267 a push, a typical winter (5) is about $1,300 and the biggest of the last 12 (13) about $3,500. |
| Seasonal (fixed fee) | One price for the winter, usually with a cap on visits. | Mostly the contractor, up to the cap. | Predictable but costly here. Think Outside’s published seasonal prices equal about 17 pushes, more than any winter in the last 12 needed. |
| Per inch (per event) | A price per storm by depth band, such as 2–6″ and 6–12″. | The HOA. | Workable. The budget’s “2 to 6 inch” wording already assumes a depth band. |
| Time and materials | Hourly crew and equipment rates plus ice melt. | The HOA. | Least suitable: hours and materials are hard to check from FCS’s office. |
Definitions from BrightView, “Snow Removal Contracts 101”. Ice melt is often billed per application on every type, so ask for that price separately.
A family-owned residential and commercial landscaper working across Utah County, with snow removal among its listed services. No website with prices or contract terms. Already the HOA’s landscaper, so it knows the common areas. The board minutes say “Logan Landscape”; confirm it’s the same firm.
Clears walkways, drive lanes and entrances. Pre-treats walkways before ice forms and comes back to de-ice when temperatures drop after a storm. Plans before the season: walks the property, marks priority areas, picks snow-pile spots and maps foot traffic. The service agreement starts automatically when snow falls. Names HOA communities as clients and serves Provo and Springville. No published prices.
The only company found that publishes prices (“starting at”): Basic Commercial $195 a push or $3,300 a season; Premium Commercial $275 a push or $4,775 a season. Dispatches at 1–2″ on the property. Handles HOAs and apartment complexes, entryways and sidewalks, de-icing, and ice melt on request. Its service area is northern Utah County: its new website (thinkoutsideutah.com) lists Highland, Lehi, American Fork and nearby, so it may not come to south Provo. Its prices are still the best benchmark available.
Family-owned for over 30 years and works for HOAs. Plows private roads and entry points; hand-shovels walkways, stairs and ramps; de-ices; hauls snow away. Says contracts signed before winter get priority. No published prices. The strongest option if the HOA does own the road.
Offers one-time clears, per-push service, full-season packages with unlimited visits, and on-demand service. Plows at 1–2″, monitors and dispatches 24/7, pre-treats before storms and de-ices after, and uses pet- and plant-safe ice melt on request. Names HOAs and townhome communities. Plow Busters’ Provo page gives the same address and billing email, so count them as one bid, not two.
C&C Grounds Maintenance (Utah County, lists Provo) does residential, HOA and commercial maintenance with plowing, de-icing and shoveling, but takes contact by email only and gives no terms (site). Chopper Landscaping works for HOAs with 24/7 emergency service, but it’s based in Salt Lake City and South Jordan, far from south Provo (site).
Checklist items draw on the contract terms in Truco Services’ Utah guide and BrightView’s article above.